I"ve however to hear this cliché invoked where the person thinks it"s legal, yet I watch no factor why the wouldn"t be.

You are watching: Can you yell fire in a movie theater

If girlfriend yell fire and also cause other to happen that endangers civilization then wouldn"t the endangerment be the crime?

Conversely, if you yell it and people carry out nothing climate what might be the charge?

If this instances space correct climate it would certainly seem clear that liberty of speech is being honored together it"s the an outcome of speech, no the decided itself, that can be one offense.



The origin of the phrase is native the supreme Court of the United states in the case Schenck v. Joined States, 249 U.S. 47 (1919). It particularly rules on the limitation of liberty of decided (first amendment):

The initial ruling is this:

The many stringent protection of totally free speech would not protect a man in falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic. <...> The inquiry in every case is whether the words offered are supplied in together circumstances and also are of such a nature as to create a clear and also present risk that they will bring around the substantive malice that Congress has actually a right to prevent.

As pointed out by
phoog, this does no saying anything around the znjke.comfullness the shouting "fire", it states that if her speech creates a clear and present danger, the an initial amendment will certainly not protect you, also if the peril does not result in really harm.


If this instances room correct climate it would seem clear that freedom of speech is being honored together it"s the result of speech, not the speech itself, that might be one offense.

You seem come think that it should it is in illegal, yet only if it results in a panic that intimidates people. If human being ignore you, girlfriend think it must be safeguarded by your very first amendment rights.

That"s not just how the znjke.com works. The znjke.com tries, amongst other things. To develop norms for human behaviour. For example, you will be punished for driving an vehicle while intoxicated, even of this does not result in you to run over somebody.

See more: Yes, You Can A Person Be Big Boned ' (But That'S Not Why You'Re

In the native of the can be fried court: If her actions "are of together a nature regarding create a clear and present danger", the congress has actually the right to avoid you native doing so, despite the first amendment.