For an apple pie pour it until it is full of tender however intact chunks of fruit, well balanced perfectly in between tart and also sweet, no all apologize are developed equal.

You are watching: Can you use red delicious apples for apple pie


But ns did notification an interesting phenomenon when I coincidentally left out a few bags the sliced apples because that a little too long:

I noticed as the apples were sitting that, relying on the variety, lock browned come a various degree. Some, favor Red Delicious, rotate dark brown nearly immediately. ~ above the other hand, also after number of hours, Granny Smiths showed only a hint of browning.

I arranged the to apologize on a key in bespeak of their level of browning.** What automatically struck me was the the least tart apple—the Red Delicious—was all the way at one end, while the many tart apple—the Granny Smith—was all the means at the other end.

** The order they are arranged in in the picture is by level the browning loved one to their initial color, i beg your pardon is why some appear to be the end of order.

This renders sense: Acid can inhibit the browning oxidation reactions the take location in fruit flesh as soon as it is exposed come the air. Because that the same reason, cooks will store trimmed artichokes in acidulated water—it stays clear of browning.

Well, there's an additional thing that mountain does: that strengthens pectin, the cement-like glue the holds together the cell of fruit. So, looking at this arranged spectrum of apples is in reality a pretty great indication of exactly how well each fruit is walk to hold up during baking. The farther to the best along the browning scale, the firmer the apple must be in the perfect pie.

After arranging the small pies in this exact same order and examining their fillings, turns out that this is certainly true. As you'll view in the photos below, the pies begin off with very mushy filling that get progressively firmer.

Flavor: really sweet and one-dimensional.Texture: Mealy flesh that transforms to mush once cooked. Skin is thick and can be rather bitter. It may look an excellent on the supermarket shelf for a long time, but is really only tasty once fresh-picked.Pie Rating (1–10): 1. fully mushy, with a an extremely one-dimensional, cloying flavor. This reminded me of bad applesauce.Best Uses: Eating the end of hand, but only when really fresh.

Flavor: Sweet and mildly tart, with very white flesh.Texture: Tender and also slightly grainy.Pie Rating (1–10): 3. it holds up far better than, say, Red very delicious in pies, yet still turns rather brown and mushy.Best Uses: Applesauce or eating out of hand.

Flavor: very sweet and also mildly tart, with a distinctive citrusy aroma, comparable to Granny blacksmith (of which that is a descendant). That becomes practically pear-like in flavor once it cooks.Texture: fairly crisp and not lot graininess. This texture seems to indicate that the indeed has a reasonably strong framework of pectin.Pie Rating (1–10): 7. it manages to soften totally while tho retaining a an excellent deal that texture as soon as baked right into an apologize pie, because of its density. It could be slightly firmer when baked. Great gold color.Best Uses: Pies, tarts, sauce, eating plain.

Flavor: very mild when eaten out that hand; not really sweet, but develops in flavor once cooked.Texture: It has actually a thick skin and really firm flesh. Despite it has a reputation as a an excellent baking apple, I uncovered it unsuitable.Pie Rating (1–10): 3. It transforms dark brown and mushy as it bakes.Best Uses: Sauce.

Flavor: fairly sweet and fresh-tasting; not cloying.Texture: fresh flesh that stays an excellent for a long time. The texture is almost pear-like in its humidity level and also crunchiness.Pie Rating (1–10): 2. The gentle flavor does no get intensified by baking. Watery however tart.Best Uses: Eating out of hand.

Flavor: Sweet, tart, and virtually buttery. Fine balanced and also rich, especially when cooked.Texture: really fresh and also quite crisp, however can border on mealy when held for too long off the tree. Once baked, the softens yet retains a little bit of texture.Pie Rating (1–10): 8. The best flavor I gained out of any single apple—this is what apologize pie should taste like. I just wish it to be slightly firmer.Best Uses: Pies, sauce, to apologize butter.

Flavor: similar to that of a McIntosh, yet much sweeter and much more tart. Choose its cousin, it's got an extremely white flesh and a mild flavor.Texture: Tender and also slightly grainy.Pie Rating (1–10): 4. it does quite well in pies texturally—softening without breaking down—but lacks in flavor.Best Uses: Applesauce or eating the end of hand.

Flavor: very sweet and very tart, with a an excellent level that juiciness, it's a cross in between a McIntosh and also a Red Delicious and also shows spices from both.Texture: regardless of its tender/grainy ancestry, its texture is quite firm and crunchy.Pie Rating (1–10): 3. once baked, it has nice texture, but becomes cloyingly sweet. The acid is tho present, yet it's not enough to fight versus the street level.Best Uses: Eating the end of hand.

Flavor: Mild and also sweet, with a fair amount the tartness, it's among the most popular apples about for its small size and an excellent resistance come bruising.Texture: an extremely thin-skinned, through a grainy texture.Pie Rating (1–10): 6. as soon as baked, that holds its shape, however the graininess can acquire overwhelming. I like my pie apologize to it is in supple and smooth-textured.Best Uses: Eating the end of hand.

Flavor: really bright and tart, with a distinct citrus aroma and white wine–like nose. Texture: very firm, crunchy, and slightly grainy.Pie Rating (1–10): 5. it holds up almost indefinitely once cooking. It has good brightness, yet not lot apple-y flavor.Best Uses: Eating the end of hand.

Now, some really astute readers could have noticed the one glaring exemption here: Braeburns space low in acid, however remain reasonably firm as they bake. Why is this?

It all has to do v air. Braeburns are fairly dense apples, with not much air in between their cells. (You deserve to see this if girlfriend drop one right into a bucket that water follow me with, say, a McIntosh: Braeburns will certainly float increase much more slowly.) apologize with lots of air will collapse on themselves, prefer a deflating balloon, as they cook. Very dense apples—like Braeburns—will maintain their shape better, even as they fully soften.

As you deserve to see from mine tasting notes, because that the most component texture certainly does boost with more tartness, but an excellent texture alone does not a good pie make.

Some folks imply mixing two varieties of apple—one to provide texture, the various other for flavor—but this never made sense to me. Say we incorporate some Granny Smiths with some Romes. What you end up through is a pie that's acquired nice certain chunks of apologize interspersed v brown apple mush.

Nope, a single apple would have to do it because that me, and the best ones in the running space the golden Delicious and also the Braeburn. They're the persons I use for all of my baking purposes.

The inquiry is, since both golden Delicious and Braeburns have actually great, well-balanced flavor, yet neither is quite firm enough when baked, is there something I can do to enhance upon your texture?

Indeed there is, and also this post is riddled with ideas on how to perform it. To acquire the complete explanation, check out the last installment in our pie-a-thon, wherein I"ll describe how to revolve your apples into the finest pie filling they can be.

room In-Season to apologize Better?

You might think the the whole "local, seasonal" movement is obtaining a bit out of hand, and also oftentimes, I tend to agree. But there are particular foods for which it truly makes sense. Apples because that pies are among them.

See, if friend aren't purchase apples directly from the orchard or picking them you yourself in the fall, possibilities are that they've been in long-term storage. Apples are stored in atmospherically regulated rooms for as much as 10 months prior to being placed on supermarket shelves. This stop wreaks havoc through their cell structure, leading to them come ripen at a vastly boosted pace when they're taken the end of storage.

This means that if girlfriend buy an apple from the supermarket in, say, June, most most likely that apple to be picked last October. In ~ a job or two, the goes from gift crisp and bake-able come mushy and unsuitable for pies.

My advice? Don't roasted apple pies except in the fall and early winter. If friend absolutely must have actually that feather or summer pie, look because that apples that room refrigerated, and get them into your own refrigerator as soon as possible. Execute not let them sit in ~ room temperature for as well long prior to cooking them.

As because that what to execute with the leftovers that 20 pies? If girlfriend ask me nicely, I can share v you a great way to make friends v your neighbors.

See more: Burt Bees Lip Balm On Eyelids ? Let A Millennial Explain Burt'S Bees To Enhance Buzz

Author"s Note: This is the 2nd of 3 Food Lab write-ups in a collection about how to make the best apple pie, start with the basics that pie crust and also ending through the right method to chef apple pie filling. Here, we"ll gain into what varieties of apples have actually the consistency and flavor we"re in search of in a pie filling—according come science.