Must faithful Catholics now give a ‘religious submission of mind and will’ to Francis’s teachings ~ above this issue?

Last week, Pope Francis made one more move to advance his teachings ~ above Communion for the divorced and remarried.

You are watching: Can you receive communion if you are divorced and remarried

In September 2016, the pope sent out a exclusive letter come bishops in Buenos Aires to clarify his teachings on the issue, i m sorry he had expressed in his apostolic exhortation Amoris Laetitia. Now, the pope asserted this letter to it is in his “authentic magisterium,” which way it is just one of his main teachings.


The pope’s letter approved of the guidelines recipe by Argentine bishops in Buenos Aires on exactly how Communion for divorced and remarried Catholics must be handled. The indict assert that, in certain circumstances, a human being who is divorced and also remarried and also is living in an active sexual partnership can not be responsible or culpable for the mortal sin that adultery, “particularly when a human being judges that he would fall into a subsequent fault by damaging the youngsters of the brand-new union.” The guidelines add that “Amoris Laetitia opens up up the opportunity of accessibility to the sacraments that Reconciliation and also the Eucharist.”

This caused confusion amongst some Catholics, that saw the statements as violating Canon 915 in the Code the Canon Law, which forbids anyone whose soul is in a state the mortal sin from receiving the Eucharist. According to the the supervisory board of Trent, a marriage cannot be dissolved by a civil divorce. Therefore, if one gets divorced and also then engages in sexual activity in a second marriage, that or she is committing adultery. If true repentance with confession can absolve this sin, one cannot have actually true repentance if one intends to continue sexual activity in this remarriage.

Pope Francis, however, in his exclusive letter, i beg your pardon is now authentic magisterium, affirmed the Buenos Aires bishops’ guidelines and also wrote that there is “no other interpretation” of Amoris Laetitia. This, the course, is hugely important: when the letter was private, it was not required that Catholics agree v this interpretation; indeed, many construed Amoris Laetitia differently. But now this translate takes an decisive position. Together the Dogmatic structure on the Church, Lumen Gentium, states, the faithful space instructed to offer a “religious entry of mind and will” come teachings that space authentic magisterium even though the teaching may not be an infallible statements on faith and also morals.


Father James Martin, S.J., a consultant to the Vatican’s Secretariat because that Communications, said me via email that Pope Francis is reaffirming the Catholic teachings top top the primacy of conscience, i m sorry Martin says have been downplayed in the critical 40 years.

“The certain teaching in inquiry (in this letter) is the those who room divorced and remarried and who have actually not obtained an annulment may, in part cases, get Communion,” boy name said. “Now, someone in his or her very own conscience may disagree through that, yet this particular teaching is directed largely at those who seek to be invited at Communion.”

According to Catechism of the Catholic Church i 1790, individuals are obligated come follow their conscience, since they have to do what lock think is right. However, paragraph 137 the Instrumentum Laboris, the “working document” that the 2015 synod top top the family, clarifies the teaching, stating that one’s conscience should be notified by the Church teachings. Otherwise, one may make “selfish” or “arbitrary” decisions.


Questions surrounding divorce and remarriage have caused conflict over the past couple of years. The regarded ambiguity that Amoris Laetitia led 4 cardinals in September 2016 to authorize the dubia — Latin for “doubts” — which contained five inquiries asking Pope Francis for clarification ~ above his views. After gift ignored by the divine Father, one of the signers, Cardinal Burke, claimed the cardinals will have to worry a official correction the the pope.


A year later, in September 2017, an ext than 60 Catholic scholar signed a filial-correction document, which take it a much harsher technique than the dubia. The filial correction alleged that Pope Francis committed 7 heresies regarding his teachings top top divorce and also remarriage and moral relativism.

One that the signers that the filial correction, Anna Silvas, told me via email that Francis’s decision to put this letter to the Buenos Aires bishops in the really magisterium mirrors that his intention is to breach “the moral and sacramental reality of the faith.” She added, “You can not obey the disobedient,” introduce to Francis.

Taking a different approach than both Martin and also Silvas, Father thomas Petri, a dean and theology professor in ~ the Dominican house of researches in Washington, D.C., said that, in spite of the dramatic reaction the some, the does no think Francis is fundamentally changing anything.

‘You can not obey the disobedient.’ 

— Anna Silvas


Father Petri suggested that the guidelines in Buenos Aires space themselves quite ambiguous and that us must analyze them based on the legacies of the Church. The guidelines, Petri sharp out, carry out not open up Communion for every divorced and remarried Catholics. Rather, Petri to trust the guidelines need to be understood as introduce to cases in i m sorry one human being in the remarriage is just submitting to sex-related acts under duress.

See more: Feeding And Breastfeeding 8 Month Old Milk Supply And Demand (For Parents)


Father Petri offered the Vademecum, a 1997 Church document, to protect his point. The Vademecum discusses contraception, i m sorry is forbidden by the Church when it is used to prevent pregnancy. It states a human being may no be culpable for cooperating with the sex-related sin if the certain acts of the cooperating person are no themselves illicit, if there room proportionally grave factors for cooperating, and if the one cooperating is do the efforts to aid the spouse avoid engaging in the conduct. All three conditions must it is in met. Petri believes these ethics can apply to the divorce-and-remarriage question.


A more comprehensive development of Communion come the divorced and also remarried, however, would certainly be “contrary to the word of Jesus Christ himself,” according to father Petri, and he doesn’t think Francis will or can permit that. Pope Francis, Petri said, “is a male of the Church.”