Increasing numbers of bears — and also bear disputes — top top the Rocky hill Front spark a invoice to rise latitude for killing.

You are watching: Can you kill a bear in self defense

byAmanda Eggert 01.22.202101.25.2021
Credit: Adobe stock. Might not it is in republished without license.

Empower her community. Strength the Press! Your ongoing support fuel the future that independent, public-powered news in Montana. Aid us with our end-of-the-year goal so we have the right to provide an ext of the report you worth every day.

Empower her community. Strength the Press! Fuel the future the independent, public-powered news in Montana. Assist us reach our end-of-the-year goal so we have the right to cover much more of the stories that matter.

A Republican lawmaker indigenous Ethridge, just east of the Rocky hill Front, presented a invoice Thursday that intends to broaden the circumstances under which civilization can legally kill grizzly bear in Montana. 

Current legislation says the legal to death or effort to death a grizzly bear in self-defense, or if the be affected by each other is “in the act of attacking or killing” livestock. Senate bill 98 would allow the death of grizzlies that are “threatening come kill” people or livestock.

Sen. Bruce “Butch” Gillespie said that when it comes to grizzly management, Montana is “stuck in a time capsule,” and that grizzless should have actually been delisted from endangered varieties protections years ago. “They long earlier hit the target that 300 . Today we’re most likely looking in ~ 1,800 come 2,000. That means there are countless times more conflicts strikes — life-and-death conflicts.”

Speaking on instead of of the bill at a hearing prior to the Senate Agriculture, Livestock and also Irrigation Committee, five farming producers recounted issues and encounters they’ve had with grizzlies. Lock outlined make the efforts they’ve made to decrease the variety of grizzlies on their properties with combined results, and also expressed disappointed with existing grizzly management. 

Calon Yeager, a rancher indigenous Choteau, said he’s uncovered as countless as nine grizzlies acquiring into serial on his ranch. The now has an electric fence about his yard that was set up by Montana Fish, Wildlife and also Parks. He claimed that although it’s generally effective, every as soon as in a if a clever bear find a means in.

What rather you should know:

OPI reports ~ above staffing vacancies and also hiring challenges


Yeager claimed he worries around the ranch hands who come to work in the early morning hours. “If those guys need to shoo a be affected by each other or shooting a bear, i would prefer them come be protected by this law,” he said.

He added that he puts a many of belief in ranchers to exercise discretion as stewards the the land. “I nothing feel like we’re going come run around with guns and pitchforks and also knives trying to follow out all of the grizzly bears,” the said. “There’s a one of life, and I think bears play a component in that.”

Shanun Rammell, another SB 98 proponent from Choteau, called current grizzly administration “unethical” and also recounted gift mauled through a young grizzly who’d acquired into a grain melted near his property last July. He’s incurred far-reaching medical debt together a result of the encounter, and also said it’s readjusted the way he moves about on his land through his wife. 

“I will never ever again walk on the morning walk through my lovely one,” that said.



Gianforte lobbies internal to delist north Continental division grizzlies

Grizzly bear are significantly coming into dispute with people and livestock, and leading come calls for decreased protections and an ext aggressive management.


Rammell’s wife, Jamie, claimed she still doesn’t feeling safe on her property, also though they’ve mounted an electrical fence encompassing eight acres neighboring their house, purchased 2 livestock security dogs and installed cameras external their home.

“I don’t desire to it is in burying my children,” she said. “ need to be afraid again favor black bear are.”

Ranchers also cited the financial losses they’ve suffered as result of grizzly conflicts. Dave McEwen, a rancher from Galata, phibìc of an excellent Falls, stated he’s had actually 75 lambs killed by grizzlies. He stated while he recognizes the SB 98 would certainly not have prevented that particular loss, that “should not have to think about the consequences to do the duty that needs to it is in done.”

“Agriculture is act a hell that a job cultivation bears,” he added. “They discovered garbanzo beans, they like barley, castle really favor pigs, and they’re working on mine sheep and cows.” 

Referencing the discussion that regulations like SB 98 would prevent delisting that the animals, McEwen said, “they’ve hung that carrot in prior of united state for how plenty of years?”

Several bill enemies spoke about delisting in their disagreements before the committee, speak it’s unlikely the U.S. Fish and also Wildlife organization would remove federal protections with laws like SB 98 top top the books in Montana. (Before USFWS will delist an intimidated species, states must show they have adequate regulatory mechanisms in place.)

Speaking on instead of of a range of preservation organizations, opponents additionally focused on the discrepancy the measure would create between federal and also state law. 

“This bill can give a false impression to some world that they have the right to kill grizzly bears when they cannot under federal law,” stated Montana Wildlife Federation Conservation manager Nick Gevock. “They would still face federal prosecution.”

Gevock, who served on former Gov. Steve Bullock’s Grizzly bear Advisory Council, also pointed out that it’s at this time legal under federal legislation to kill a be afflicted with in self-defense.

Gevock outlined efforts that have been proven efficient in mitigating the conflicts between humans and also grizzlies. Such changes include picking up carcasses, fencing turn off attractants like beehives and calving yards, and also using variety riders come establish much more of a human being presence on the landscape. He said bear problems in the Blackfoot Valley have actually dropped 93% end the last two decades due to this measures.

Speaking on behalf of the Montana Audubon Society, Carmen Borchelt characterized grizzly monitoring as a “complex and also patient endeavor,” and said she’s involved that Gillespie’s proposal wouldn’t select for problem bears.

See more: Can You Get Inhalers Over The Counter Asthma Inhaler: What Are Your Options?

Sen. Kenneth Bogner, R-Miles City, request Gillespie if he’d be receptive to adding an amendment come repeal the measure in the occasion of grizzly delisting to address the potential for USFWS to postpone delisting ~ above account of SB 98.

Gillespie stated he’d have to speak v some people about it first, however added, “on the surface, I sort of prefer the idea.”