Disclosure statement

John M. Murphy go not work-related for, consult, very own shares in or receive resources from any firm or organization that would advantage from this article, and also has disclosed no appropriate affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

You are watching: Can joe biden win the presidency


View all partners

Joe Biden winner the election, but whether he wins the transition is an additional question. The calm transfer that power constantly tests an just arrive president, yet this time promises to be an especially perilous.

The coronavirus pandemic is accelerating, acquisition lives and also jobs together it spreads. The incumbent, chairman Donald Trump, has only reluctantly agreed come the transition and knows how to dominate the nationwide conversation. The seems figured out to refuse his successor’s legitimacy and also appears to it is in planning a 2024 project rally top top Inauguration Day.

In the transition time remaining, I believe Biden demands to develop two type of legitimacy. The should display the nation that he possesses the competence to setup an administration, in stimulate to produce substantive legitimacy. And he must perform necessary ceremonial rituals, in bespeak to establish symbolic legitimacy.

As a scholar that the presidency, i have written about John Kennedy’s transition, i beg your pardon culminated in his superb inaugural address. Biden appears unlikely to complement that rhetorical achievement, yet he is off to a heavy start.


president Donald trumped speaks throughout a rally to assistance Republican Senate candidates in Valdosta, Ga. On Dec. 5, 2020. Picture by Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/AFP via Getty pictures

This one’s different

The president-elect has actually sought to handmade his substantive legitimacy through comparison and contrast. One of these presidents, Biden suggests, is not prefer the other.

This is no an unexplained strategy. Democratic political consultant David Axelrod long earlier coined the opposites theory of presidential elections, noting, “Voters rarely seek the replica of what lock have.” President-elect Biden appears to assume the he winner at least in part because voter rejected Donald Trump, and so he has actually reinforced the difference between the two throughout the beforehand transition.

When the election hung in the balance, the previous vice president waited for the outcomes with the remainder of us. Uneven Trump, Biden refused to explain victory, noting only that “We feel an excellent about wherein we are.” His humility contrasted to Trump’s behavior throughout his term.

When the an outcome became clear, Biden not only supported national unity in his Nov. 7 speech, he additionally shared the phase with evil President-elect Kamala Harris. The was a perk denied Biden on election night in 2008 and also an indication that he planned come govern no as a rogue individual but as part of a team.

His very first staff and cabinet choices have reinforced the collaboration theme. “Competence is making a comeback,” the connected Press asserted in its analysis of Biden’s nationwide security selections. The president-elect quietly made his decisions, through no publicly auditions or press leaks. He presented them as a team in a sober setting. Each provided remarks emphasizing your commitments to morality and honesty.

For example, his nominee for Secretary that State, Anthony Blinken, movingly said the Holocaust survive story that his stepfather, announcing a ethical mission for the United states in the world. Avril Haines, nominated for Director of national Intelligence, stated she would certainly speak reality to power, “knowing that you would never ever want me to carry out otherwise and that you worth the perspective of the intelligence community, and that friend will perform so also when what I have to say might be inconvenient or difficult.”

Joe Biden is plainly determined to dissociate his management from the previous one, i m sorry was defined by neither ethical commitment nor belief in truth. He is do his substantive legitimacy through demonstrating his belief in teamwork, morality, competence and also experience. His administration, he insurance claims with this choices, is prepared to lead.


Biden, left, and Harris, right, appear jointly at numerous events. Chandan Khanna/AFP via Getty pictures

Symbolic legitimacy

Biden is amongst the most experienced candidates chosen to the presidency. However assuming the office will be difficult, also for him. He has actually been a senator and vice president, however he has not remained in charge.

To come to be the president needs ritual.

A chairman is both the legislative branch leader and the head the state, the tantamount of a British prime minister and also the queen in one. The trappings of the office make the office. Americans need to see Biden invested through the presidency, lot as a Prince the Wales becomes the king by suspect the robes and also powers that his office in a ceremony.

The inaugural ceremony on Jan. 20 is a routine of transition that transforms “Joe” right into a head that state, into Mr. President. The inaugural attend to gives the the possibility to demonstrate his presidential capacity, to unite partisans together one people, and also display himself together their leader.

<Expertise in your inbox. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter and get professional takes top top today’s news, every day.>

The Founders interpreted the human need because that political consciousness at time of transition. George Washington learned the his an initial election to the presidency on April 14, 1789 and soon left his mountain Vernon heritage in Virginia for the then-capital of brand-new York City.

Washington’s trip turned right into a cool celebration the the new nation. In Trenton, new Jersey, for example, 13 young women, pull in white, walked prior to him, strewing flower from baskets together he rode under a magnificent floral arch. Washington was no longer a gentleman farmer nor also a general. That was around to end up being the president and also these species of rituals marked the way.

Biden is i can not qualify to undertake such a trip from Wilmington to Washington, back Axios has reported the Biden might ditch the recent inaugural tradition, “the typical flourish of arriving in Washington on one Air force plane, pulling in instead on the same Amtrak train that rode to and also from Delaware because that 30 years together a senator.”


A lithograph of Washington’s agree by ladies, on happen the leg at Trenton, N.J., April 1789, ~ above his means to brand-new York to it is in inaugurated first president the the joined States. Nathaniel Currier/Smithsonian American art Museum

If Biden is to develop his symbolic legitimacy together a rightful chairman of the unified States, the will need a ceremony displaying that legitimacy, one that looks and also sounds like those that his predecessors. This will certainly be hard in a pandemic, as the campaign showed. He was unable to project as a candidate typically would or give his choice night decided in former of a roaring crowd, as, because that example, Barack Obama did in Chicago’s grant Park in 2008.

Now, it appears unlikely that he will be able to take the oath in a big ceremony or enjoy plenty of of the traditional trappings the a presidential inauguration. Biden has said his inauguration might “resemble the autonomous National Convention.”

Although the 2020 convention to be successful, it no look favor the timeless inaugural ceremonies. Together a model, it would certainly deprive the country of many of the comforting rituals. It would substitute a small, televised ceremony in ~ the Capitol and virtual activities from roughly the nation.

See more: Coming Into Los Angeles, Bringing In A Couple Of Keys, Coming Into Los Angeles Misheard Lyrics

The president-elect and also his advisers will have actually to find ways to do these new traditions authorize his presidency and also the old ones. I execute not envy lock this task.