COVID science Update – challenge Coverings

A current study has shown there are much more effective varieties of masks and also facial coverings.

You are watching: Can bandanas be used as face mask

Fischer et al., (2020) tested relative droplet counts in the air once subjects spoke while attract various varieties of confront coverings.Cite: Fischer et al. (2020). Low-cost measure up of confront mask efficacy because that filtering expelled droplets throughout speech. Science Advances, 6(36). Https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abd3083

Their data shown several types of masks and also facial coverings were very effective in lowering family member droplet counts. That said, a few were displayed to be ineffective.

The Test

*
There to be fourteen different face coverings tested.

Surgical mask (three layers)Valved N95 mask (N95 mask through exhalation valve)Knitted maskPolyproline mask (Two-layer polypropylene apron mask)Poly/cotton mask (Cotton-polypropylene-cotton mask)MaxAT mask (One-layer Maxima at mask)Cotton2 mask (Two-layer cotton, pleated layout mask)Cotton4 mask (Two-layer cotton, Olson layout mask)Cotton3 mask (Two-layer cotton, pleated style mask)Cotton1 mask (One-layer cotton, pleated layout mask)Neck Gaiter (One-layer polyester/spandex, 0.022 g/cm2)Bandana (Double-layer bandana, 0.014 g/cm2)Cotton5 mask (Two-layer cotton, pleated layout mask)Fitted N95 (N95 mask, no exhalation valve, fitted)

Each confront covering to be worn through a speaker that spoke with the mask into the check area through a camera in ~ the other finish of the test area. A laser beam was scattered in a level the speaker and the camera. Droplets were photographed by the camera and also then counted. This was repeated 10 times because that each confront covering. A baseline to be taken through the speaker wearing no face covering to watch what the droplet count would be. This was collection to the “Relative droplet count” that 1.0.

See more: Can You Get Spectrum App On Ps4 ? Can You Access Spectrum App On Ps4

Droplet infection through confront masks check Results

*
From the study, “Each heavy data point represents the mean and SD over 10 trials for the same mask, normalized come the manage trial (no mask), and tested by one speaker. Hollow data points space the mean and also SDs of the relative counts over 4 speakers.”

Test results display that most common masks execute a fairly an excellent job in ~ obstructing droplets. However, two very noticeable exceptions are the Bandana (#12) and Neck Gaiter (#11). The material in the Neck Gaiter actually seems to break bigger particles apart for this reason increasing the aerosol spread much more than the baseline the no confront covering.

These essential results suggested several varieties of masks and also face coverings perform better than bandanas and gaiters for protecting civilization by reducing the spread of respiratory tract droplets.