The default position is the Catholics need to not be refuse communion other than for a serious reason. The code of Canon legislation states, “Sacred ministers cannot refuse the sacraments to those who seek them at ideal times, are appropriately disposed, and are no prohibited by regulation from receiving them.” However, it additionally says the those “who obstinately persist in manifest dig sin are not to it is in admitted to holy Communion.”

The challenges come indigenous deciding that obstinately stubborn in manifesting dig sin and also how this should be addressed. Over there are currently two circumstances that are an especially controversial: communion for divorced and remarried couples who have not had an annulment and also communion for Catholic politicians who either expropriate or promote legal abortion. The preferred strategy is because that a priest to interact with people privately and also persuade them no to present themselves because that communion till the case is corrected.

You are watching: Can a priest refuse to give communion

Withholding communion from who is not a statement on the standing of the person’s soul, however rather it is a reaction to publicly accessible information that shows the human being is no in “communion” v the church and its teachings. On this occasions, the reception of communion can cause others to doubt or misunderstand church teaching.


Because Catholics who space divorced and remarried (without one annulment) are objectively in a case contrary come church teaching, in the past the church taught the they can not receive communion. This self-control (not doctrine) readjusted somewhat v Pope Francis’ apostolic exhortation Amoris Laetitia (On Love in the Family), wherein he permits for the possibility that some divorced and remarried world might have the ability to receive communion. This change continues to be controversial.

Because of president Joe Biden, a practicing Catholic who has embraced and/or promoted legal abortion, the issue of even if it is he (and other Catholic political leaders in comparable circumstances) should receive communion has come to be a subject of debate. Cardinal louis Ladaria, the prefect the the Congregation of the doctrine of the Faith, freshly sent part guidance concerning the concern to Archbishop José Gomez, chairman of the United says Conference of Catholic Bishops. According to Ladaria, any kind of national policy on the eucharistic coherence of one’s life with one’s belief cannot supersede the authority of an individual bishop in his own diocese to decision whether Catholic politicians must receive communion. Over there is no consensus amongst the U.S. Bishops top top the matter.

See more: Ootd: Black With A Touch Of Gold Outfits, Black On Black With A Touch Of Gold


In one of two people of these situations, a monk can and sometimes should withhold communion. However, denying a Catholic communion must never be excellent without early out prayer and discernment. It have to never be excellent for any reason various other than the activity is taken as important for the an excellent of every the faithful and for the good of the person being denied communion. 

This article also appears in theOctober 2021issue the U.S. Catholic (Vol. 86, No. 10, page 49).Click hereto subscribe to the magazine.

Image:Unsplash/Gabriella Clare Marino


*

Father Paul Keller, C.M.F.Father Paul Keller, C.M.F. Is a Catholic priest and a Claretian Missionary. He is currently a doctoral college student in theology and also the ideology of religion. Dad Paul Keller’s digital column, Smells like sheep, focuses on the areas where pastoral ministry, windy policy, theology, and also ethics converge. You have the right to like the on on facebook or monitor him top top Twitter