Pastor Ché Ahn speak at Harvest rock Church in Pasadena, California in 2019 (left) and on Feb. 28, 2020. Photos: Harvest absent Church on facebook page.

You are watching: California bans in-home bible studies

“This bespeak frees up church in all of California to have indoor services, again.” – Liberty Counsel

By Allen Payton

In the sue by Pasadena-based Harvest rock Church and also Harvest worldwide Ministry versus Governor Gavin Newsom over his half on all worship services and Bible researches in California, the U.S. Can be fried Court ruled, yesterday, Thursday, Dec. 3, 2020, in favor of the church. The decision vacates the September 2 bespeak by the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals and also directs the court come the can be fried Court’s recent 5-4 decision in favor of the roman Catholic Diocese that Brooklyn in their lawsuit against new York branch Andrew Cuomo.

The U.S. Can be fried Court granted cert and vacated the lower court orders including the emergency petition of Harvest absent Church and also Harvest worldwide Ministry. The Court declared in that order:

“The applications for injunctive relief, gift to justice Kagan and also by her described the Court, is treated together a petition because that a writ of certiorari before judgment, and also the petition is granted. The September 2 bespeak of the United says District Court because that the main District the California is vacated, and the instance is remanded to the United claims Court of Appeals for the ninth Circuit v instructions come remand come the ar Court because that further factor to consider in light of Roman Catholic Diocese the Brooklyn v. Cuomo, 592 U. S. ___ (2020).”

Tuesday, Liberty Counsel filed the final reply brief to the U.S. Supreme Court about its request for one injunction pending very nice in the churches’ federal lawsuit against California branch Gavin Newsom’s unconstitutional worship ban and also discriminatory treatment. The emergency petition additionally requested the especially relief that the Court additionally consider it together a petition because that writ that cert before judgment. Today, the supreme Court granted the petition, vacated the lower court orders, and also remanded the case for further factor to consider in light of its ruling last week the granted an injunction pending appeal for churches and also synagogues in brand-new York.

According to the complaint by the church and ministry, referred to as the plaintiffs, “On July 17, 2020, Plaintiffs filed their complaint against Defendant California governor Gavin Newsom. (“Complaint,” Dkt. No. 1.) The complain alleges six reasons of action: (1) Violation of cost-free Exercise clause of an initial Amendment to U.S. Constitution; (2) Violation of an initial Amendment flexibility of Assembly Clause; (3) Violation of cost-free Speech i of first Amendment to U.S. Constitution; (4) Violation of facility Clause of very first Amendment come U.S. Constitution; (5) Violation of Equal security Clause of Fourteenth Amendment come U.S. Constitution; and (6) Violation the the Guarantee i of the U.S. Constitution.”

Then, “On July 18, 2020, Plaintiffs filed a activity for short-term Restraining Order and also Preliminary Injunction.”

According to Liberty Counsel, the for sure representing the church and ministry, they then appealed the instance to the nine Circuit Court the Appeals regarding Governor Gavin Newsom’s unconstitutional orders. The governor’s orders prohibit all indoor worship, including home bible studies and also fellowship with anyone who does no live in the home. Yet, Gov. Newsom proceeds to encourage massive gatherings that protestors transparent the state.

Following the dispute on august 12, judge Jesus G. Bernal orally denied the inquiry for a preliminary injunction. However, he waited until September 2 to release the written order. The appeal to be filed, however it might not be efficient until a composed order was issued.

Once the order had actually been issued, the appeal was able to proceed. Liberty Counsel also filed for an injunction pending appeal. The is what the can be fried Court granted.


On respectable 13, the Pasadena Assistant Prosecutor in the Criminal department sent Harvest absent Church and also Pastor Che’ Ahn a letter demanding that all, indoor, in-person worship services cease. The letter threatens day-to-day criminal charges and fines to minister Ahn, the church, staff, and also parishioners. The letter claims that every criminal fee is punishable by up to one year in prison.”

The lawsuit obstacles both the complete ban on indoor, in-person worship (including in personal homes) in the counties top top the “County monitoring List,” and also the half on singing and also chanting in the remaining counties. In addition to in-person prayer at Harvest absent Church, the church likewise has many “Life Groups,” which room home scriptures studies and also fellowship groups. This too space prohibited under Gov. Newsom’s July 6 (no singing and also chanting) and also July 13 (no worship) orders. However while that discriminates against churches, home holy bible studies and also fellowship meetings, the governor continues to encourage countless protestors to conference throughout the state. Like Gov. Newsom, Pasadena has allowed hundreds and also thousands that protestors. No the Pasadena Public health Department nor the Pasadena Prosecutor have actually attempted to avoid the protests in which human being are overfilled together, plenty of of them not wearing masks.

In branch Newsom’s response to the movement for the short-lived restraining order and also preliminary injunction, he suggests that churches room not “essential.” regarding feeding, counseling and also housing people in the same building where worship solutions occur, Newsom says that just the worship services must be prohibited while the other non-religious services need to be allowed.

Concerning home bible studies, Newsom says that he has actually authority come prohibit home fellowship groups. As to protests, Newsom publicly urges them, saying “God bless you. Store doing it.”

The restrictions against places of prayer in California are an ext severe than those in new York. Branch Gavin Newsom’s orders half all indoor, in-person praise for 99.1 percent the Californians.

Harvest absent Church has multiple campuses in California, consisting of in Pasadena, Los Angeles, Irvine and also Corona. Harvest global Ministries (HIM) has actually 162 member church throughout the state. Irreparable harm is being experienced every day together the churches stay subject come the unconstitutional restrictions, coupled with everyday criminal threats, fines, and closure.

The code Enforcement department for the City the Pasadena and also the Criminal Prosecutor have actually threatened criminal charges, fines, and closure because that being open for worship versus the governor’s orders and local health orders. The letters threaten as much as one year in prison, everyday criminal charges and $1,000 fines against the pastors, staff, and parishioners.

The discrimination has actually become much more obvious and also severe in Gov. Newsom’s brand-new “Blueprint” authorize on respectable 28, 2020, which created a system of four Tiers. The “Blueprint” discriminates against spiritual meetings in churches and also places of prayer in every Tier. The chart attached come the petition provides this discrimination very clear. Because that example, the consequence of the sea of violet in the “color-coded executive edict” is that indoor worship services are fully prohibited because that 99.1 percent of Californians, consisting of most that Harvest Rock and also HIM churches. However, warehouses, big box centers, purchase malls, liquors stores, family entertainment and also destination centers, gyms, fitness centers, and also museums receive preferential treatment through either no capacity borders or no number limits.

See more: Big East Women’S Basketball Tournament 2019, Big East Announces 2019

Liberty Counsel Founder and also Chairman Mat Staver said, “Today’s ruling by the supreme Court provides good relief for churches and places that worship. The handwriting is now on the wall. The last days of branch Gavin Newsom’s ‘color-coded executive edicts’ banning worship room numbered and also coming to an end. That is previous time to finish these unconstitutional restrictions on locations of worship.”

This stimulate frees up churches in every one of California to have actually indoor services, again.